Andrew Luck’s unexpected retirement in 2019 shocked the NFL and redefined what it means to walk away at the top. Behind the fame and fortune lies a hidden cost that even the brightest stars can’t always bear — the weight of expectations, injuries, and the constant noise that comes with being QB1.

We’re a quarter of the way through the NFL season, and the standings are starting to take shape — but don’t let the records fool you. From the surging Colts to the fading Chiefs, the question isn’t just who’s winning; it’s who’s legit. In this week’s Contrary to Popular Opinion, we break down which teams are the Real Deal and which ones are No Deal — and you might be surprised who lands where.