top of page

What Does It Mean to be a ‘Real’ Fan?

3 minutes ago
4 min read

One of the things I miss most about my dad is that he had this uncanny ability to get into pretty much any game, no matter what it was. Just flipping around the TV, he’d find something on a random sports channel that would capture his interest. A Division III basketball game between two teams he never heard of? Sure. Some low-rent golf tournament being played in Slovakia? Yup. Minor league hockey all-star game? Why not? He just loved sports and could immediately be engrossed in the competition.

 

Of course, he didn’t always enjoy everything he watched. I’ve previously written about his love-hate (that latter one, more often than not) relationship with the New York Jets. While the team’s ineptitude didn’t kill him, it certainly didn’t do him any good. Yet, bad game after bad game, bad season after bad season, he’d come back for more.

 

In the eyes of most people, my dad would have been considered a “real” fan, somebody who no matter what happened to their team, kept dutifully waving the banner. But, he also wasn’t shy about showing his disgust, whether it was due to poor play, terrible coaching decisions, or horrible draft choices (remember Christian Hackenberg?!). When you’re a fan, two things can be true at the same time: You can love your team and root for your guys, but you can also still be critical when it’s deserved.

 

Not everybody gets this, however. Recently, a couple of people seemed to imply that “real” fans have to remain blindly loyal, regardless of how teams or players perform. One of these was Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott. When asked about fan impatience after a Week 1 loss – and another hyped up off-season – he said:

 

“I mean, it's a long season. I love our fans, but I don't necessarily feel like I need to speak to that fan, you know? Sorry for them. If they're a real fan, they'll stick with it. They'll trust it. They'll believe in it. And at the end of the day like we just said, it is one game.”

 

This wasn’t the first time Prescott made such comments. During training camp before the 2023 season, he was asked about the fans being upset with how the previous season ended – a blowout loss to the Green Bay Packers. Prescott said: “Be fans or don’t be fans. If you’re a fan, you’re going to turn the page just as we do, you’re gonna move forward, understanding that you have better ahead of you. … Sorry, obviously, but it hurt us more than it did them. Obviously it’s on us to get back and to do better, but, yeah, move on.”

 

Prescott, who may be the most thin-skinned player in the NFL, also earlier this year had a run-in with a fan after the Cowboys lost to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. While walking back to the locker room after the game, a stadium worker called out “embarrassing,” to which an agitated Prescott responded by asking for the person to be removed. (To his credit, Jerry Jones – who can be highly sensitive to criticism himself – said he didn’t have a problem with fans expressing their negative opinions about the team.)

 

Another player who appears to share Prescott’s sentiment about fans is Toronto Blue Jays first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. In 2025, he and the Blue Jays were riding high. In the first year of his new massive $500 million contract, he had a very good campaign and the team nearly won it all. 2026 was another story completely however, and Guerrero had the worst season of his career, and Toronto finished in the basement of their division. He also had some very interesting things to say.

 

First, about all that money he got, he said he received it not for what he’ll do in the future, but for what he had already done. Considering he’s under contract for another 12 years, this may make people a little nervous. He also had some choice words for disparaging fans:

 

“You know how it is with fans, when you're good, they're with you 100%. But when you smell like s---, like we like to say here, nobody supports you. The ones who support you are the ones who stay with you. Those are my real fans and I considered them my family.”

 

Now, most fans understand the pressures athletes face and that nobody wants to lose or play badly. But does this entitle them to be completely shielded from any sort of criticism when they underperform? Should we not be allowed to speak out when owners act like they don’t care if their teams win or lose? Should we just “move on,” as Prescott suggested?

 

The bottom line comes down to this: You’re a “real” fan if you love your team. You’re not obligated, however, to always be in love with your team. A sentiment I’m sure my dad would agree with.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

A WORD FROM OUR SPONSORS

Keeping our pockets jingling.

HeaderStrip_4x.webp
  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
bottom of page