The 2025 MLB MVP debate is heating up. Seattle’s Cal Raleigh has emerged as a powerhouse behind the plate, launching 60 homers and redefining what a catcher can be. Meanwhile, Aaron Judge remains elite in New York, and Kyle Schwarber’s leadership and clutch hitting in Philadelphia have him squarely in the mix. This deep dive explores who truly deserves baseball’s most coveted award — and why “valuable” means more than just numbers.